Iconocast Logo

Welcome To Iconocast

How to add a URL link from your web site to the Iconocast web sites

Virtual tour of Southern California
blank

 

Recent News and Articles on the Keywords: counterfactual thinking + done differently + study  Related to the article below (Last Update: 5/5/2008)

We've Got Your Back, Bernanke
Motley Fool - Apr 23, 2008
It's simply a counterfactual. And while counterfactuals can be fun and helpful to analysis, they cannot under any circumstances be assumed to be fact. ...
Does your policy work? Toss a coin to find out
On Line opinion, Australia - Apr 29, 2008
In judging the effectiveness of any intervention, we want to know the counterfactual: what would have happened if we had not intervened? ...

New York Times
The Nation Gore-Lieberman: A Hyphen Apart? Try Poles
New York Times, United States - Apr 19, 2008
It is tempting, for fans of counterfactual history, to play out what kind of drama might have emerged in a White House under that ticket?s auspices. ...
Five Northwestern Professors Receive Guggenheims
PressZoom (press release), Netherlands - Apr 16, 2008
... natural categories and their understanding of counterfactual sentences. Rips is the author of ?The Psychology of Proof: Deduction in Human Thinking? and ...
Source: Google News

Rape and Accident Counterfactuals: Who Might Have Done Otherwise and Would It Have Changed the …
NR Branscombe, S Owen, TA Garstka, J Coleman - Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 1996 - Blackwell Synergy
... Previous research on counterfactual thinking has either employed scenarios ...
COUNTERFACTUAL FOCUS 1049 ... what the assailant could have done differently to prevent ...

The lessons we (don?t) learn: Counterfactual thinking and organizational accountability after a … -
MW Morris, PC Moore - Administrative Science Quarterly, 2000 - JSTOR
... insights about "what can be done to prevent ... contained some kind of counter- factual
statement ... with literature indicating that counterfactual thinking is spurred ...

[PDF] Counterfactual thinking -
NJ Roese - Psychological Bulletin, 1997 - psych.uiuc.edu
... In that study, participants tended to mutate whichever ... by thinking he could have
done better by ... Wong & Weiner, 1981) and because counterfactual thinking is far ...
-

Missed opportunities: Psychological ramifications of counterfactual thought in midlife women -
J Landman, EA Vandewater, AJ Stewart, JE Malley - Journal of Adult Development, 1995 - Springer
... imagining what might have been done differently, that is ... life targeted by these
counterfactual thoughts ... The overall rate of counter- factual thinking observed in ...

[PDF] Counterfactual Thinking About Actions and Failures to Act -
RMJ Byrne, A McEleney - Learning, Memory, 2000 - tcd.ie
... COUNTERFACTUAL THINKING ... and to generate greater frequency of counterfactual thoughts
than ... a short-term perspective, when the counter- factual consequences are ...
-

The Functional Theory of Counterfactual Thinking
K Epstude, NJ Roese - Personality and Social Psychology Review, 2008 - psr.sagepub.com
... two mechanisms underlying the consequences of counterfactual Problem Upward Counter
factual ?Should have done ... thinking: contrast effects and causal inference ...
-

Application of Fairness Theory to Service Failures and Service Recovery -
JR Mccoll-Kennedy, BA Sparks - Journal of Service Research, 2003 - jsr.sagepub.com
... or y? If they could have done this and ... Thus, counter- factual thinking is similar
to attribution in that ... outcome was carried out, counterfactual thinking is an ...

Children's use of counterfactual thinking in causal reasoning -
PL Harris, T German, P Mills - Cognition, 1996 - Elsevier
... compatible with Mackie's proposal that such thinking can also ... the outcome occurred)
and a counterfactual sequence (in ... also what could have been done to prevent ...

Effect of counterfactual and factual thinking on causal judgements -
DR Mandel - Thinking & Reasoning, 2003 - ingentaconnect.com
... to select different antecedents in counter- factual and causal ... COUNTERFACTUAL AND
FACTUAL THINKING 255 ... l and 2, the wording of the counterfactual prompt to ...

Explaining Injustice: The Interactive Effect of Explanation and Outcome on Fairness Perceptions and … -
JA Colquitt, JM Chertkoff - Journal of Management, 2002 - jom.sagepub.com
... differently; (2) should have done something differently; and ... 2001: 5). Put differently,
if individuals ... of the literature on counterfactual thinking, Roese (1997 ...

Source: Google Scholar

Counterfactual Thinking Study Sheds Light On How We Would Have Done Things Differently
If you're like most people, you've probably experienced a shoulda-woulda-coulda moment; a time when we lament our missteps, saying that we should have invested in a certain stock, should have become a doctor instead of a lawyer and so on.

Psychologists refer to this process, in which we evaluate how we would do things differently, as 'counterfactual thinking' and while it can have a positive spin, more often than not it is a psychological mechanism that causes us to harbor feelings of disappointment and regret.

In order to study counterfactual thinking, researchers are fond of having participants read stories in which the main character makes decisions that will ultimately doom him or her to failure and then ask these same participants how they would have done things differently.
But this method may not provide a complete picture of this mental process. New research published in the June issue of Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science, shows that our counterfactual thinking may be markedly different when we are actually experiencing failure rather than reading about someone else's.

In a series of experiments, Vittorio Girotto of the University IUAV of Venice, Italy and his colleagues attempted to demonstrate and explain the differences in counterfactual thinking between actors (those actually experiencing the problem) and readers (those who merely read about the problem).

The experiments went like this: Subjects were first divided into 'actor' and 'reader' groups. The actors were then asked to participate in a game in which they could win a reward by solving a math problem. They were then asked to choose one of two sealed envelopes: One was said to contain a difficult problem, and one supposedly contained an easy problem. In reality, both envelopes contained a problem that was nearly impossible to solve in the allotted time. Once the actors inevitably failed, they were asked to write at least one way in which things would have been better for them.

In the reader condition, subjects read a story with a protagonist who faced the same choice and ended with the same negative outcome as the subjects did in the actor condition. Like the actors, readers were required to write at least one way in which things would have been better for the protagonist.

As predicted by the researchers, readers and actors exhibited markedly different tendencies in their counterfactual thinking. In particular, readers tended to undo the protagonist's choice to tackle the problem at hand (e.g., "If she had picked the other envelope"). Actors, on the other hand, altered the features of the problem solving process (e.g., "If the use of calculator was admitted").

These results run counter to previous theories of counterfactual thinking. It was assumed that people who read a story construct the same counterfactuals as people who experienced the events described in the story. Moreover, it was believed that actors tend to avoid self-blame at all costs when thinking of alternatives. Instead, the actor-reader differences emerged even in conditions in which actors' decisions were unblameworthy. As the researchers write, "Actors and readers produce different counterfactuals because they rely on different information, not because they have different motivations."
Author: Vittorio Girotto

Psychological Science is ranked among the top 10 general psychology journals for impact by the Institute for Scientific Information.

Wiley-Blackwell was formed in February 2007 as a result of the merger between Blackwell Publishing Ltd. and John Wiley & Sons, Inc.'s Scientific, Technical, and Medical business. Together, the companies have created a global publishing business with deep strength in every major academic and professional field. Wiley-Blackwell publishes approximately 1,250 scholarly peer-reviewed journals and an extensive collection of books with global appeal. For more information on Wiley-Blackwell, please visit http://www.blackwellpublishing.com/ or http://interscience.wiley.com/.

Source: Catherine West
Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
 
 
Google
Web www.iconocast.com

Search inside Iconocast for the keyword you have in mind.

Iconocast has collected more than 50,000 articles and press releases on health and science.

These are current and most up to date press releases on the subject you are searching.

We collect current health and science press releases daily from more than 5000 research and health institutes. Here is an example : The elderberry way to perfect skin

We believe if you do search inside Iconocast, you will get better results than searching the web alone.

 
 
Continue News With: News3 ; News4 ; News5 ; News6 ; News7 ; News8 ; News9 ; News9A


ADVERTISEMENT

Iconocast is about learning and teaching without borders; we offer eMarketing, Internet Advertising, Internet Marketing, Search Engine Optimization, Search Engine Marketing, Online Branding, and eMarketing News Services.

 

Iconocast Home Page

Contact Iconocast

© 2003-07. ICONOCAST is a trademark of iconocast.com.